Say Nothing: A True Story of Murder and Memory in Northern Ireland is a 2018 non-fiction book by Patrick Radden Keefe. It focuses on The Troubles in Northern Ireland following the kidnapping and murder of Jean McConville, a widowed mother of ten children, whose family was ultimately destroyed by her murder.

I would like to start off by saying how I just cannot get over, since I was old enough to know what it was, that the Irish/UK named this bloody, armed conflict ‘The Troubles’ like they’re discussing a pair of disobedient shih tzus and not several decades worth of paramilitary organizations terrorism and guerrilla warfare. It absolutely floors me to this day.

Anyway, Say Nothing was probably my favorite non-fiction book in 2020. I didn’t do as many non-fiction books in 2020 as in years past, but I did do a fair few (some dense) and this was probably my favorite one. In a conflict with no shortage of characters and role players, Keefe did a very good job of digging into the personalities and politics of key players in the IRA since 1972, including Dolours and Marian Price.

I didn’t – still don’t – have a particularly good grip on the history and politics surrounding The Troubles. Keefe did a good job explaining a lot of the key elements of the conflict, but there’s obviously a lot more than can fit into any single volume. He combines the history, politics, and biographies into this book and ultimately uses Jean McConville’s murder as a lens to reflect on what these extremely brutal conflicts meant to the people affected by them.

Keefe also claims to have solved McConville’s murder. McConville’s murder was considered particularly outrageous as she was the only caregiver of ten children. Keefe used the testimony of two of three of McConville’s kidnappers – Pat McClure and Dolours Price – as well as other independent corroborators to deduce the third ‘Unknown’ (a highly secretive group within the IRA) that pulled the trigger. The former IRA members had said that they wouldn’t be naming the person because the person was still alive, but considering Keefe’s deductions I’m inclined to say he was right.

Say Nothing was an excellent book that I went back to physically buy after completing the audiobook. It’s a keeper. Last item of note: Keefe takes the title from Seamus Heaney’s poem ‘Whatever You Say, Say Nothing.’

Tagged: authors: patrick radden keefe, books: say nothing, genre: history, genre: non-fiction, genre: true crime