words in scarlet ink

Evelyn Hardcastle will be murdered at 11 PM. Over the course of eight days, the protagonist wakes up in the body of a new inhabitant of Blackheath House with a new chance to prevent the murder. If he fails to discover the murderer by 11 PM, the cycle repeats again. He puts information together over the course of the eight days, and if he doesn’t solve the crime in eight days, he will wake up where he was at the start (of the novel) with his memory wiped. Our protagonist cannot leave the Blackheath House until he solves the murder.

Stuart Turton’s The 7^1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle was probably my favorite novel of 2020. It was a compelling mystery and I really liked the format of repeating the same day over and over from different points of view. I’m a big Agatha Christie fan, and this felt very much like an Agatha Christie mystery, with clues scattered through many of the chapters. I did originally consume this book as an audiobook so I only remember some of the clues but after I gifted the book to my uncle as a birthday gift, he assured me that there were a lot of clues about.

Other things I liked were the setting – I love a good Locked Room mystery and that’s essentially what this was – and I loved loved LOVED that there was a Plague Doctor running around. I always liked the whole Plague Doctor mask/concept/backstory of what a plague doctor was in general, and then I picked up this book during the Covid lockdown.

I won’t spoil the ending, but it was pretty unsettling in the sense that it pointed to something extremely dystopian or sort of like a supernatural explanation (a no-no in mysteries). Aside from the sort of bizarre explanation for what was going on though, I loved this story. I found the ending so-so and I still loved it so much it was still probably my favorite book of 2020. 10/10 would recommend.